Best MLB Handicappers in the World

Here at Capper Reviews, we have an All Star roster packed with arguably the Best MLB Handicappers in the World. The beauty of betting on baseball is that it’s such a long season, with a full slate of games almost every day all summer long. This makes it easier to separate the creme from the top, the wheat from the chaff or the men from the boys and crown the best baseball capper.

It’s usually ill-advised to make a judgment based on short-term results, and that’s why we normally promote handicappers with a long history of winning. The baseball season is a seven-month marathon, and when the smoke clears most pros have made baseball predictions for more than 300 games. While some might find this a daunting task, the best baseball cappers in the business see it as a golden opportunity to line their and their clients’ wallets with the bookmaker’s money.

Our All Time Top 5 Money Earners with Baseball

Top MLB Handicappers 2026

Things can change from year to year, and sometimes new faces rise to the top, while old dogs die hard. While there is still plenty of baseball yet to be played, there are a few handicappers than have separated themselves from the crowd. Have a look at our top money earners with Major League Baseball in 2026:

CAPPERS LEADERBOARD
Rank Handicapper Profit ROI Win PCT W-L Avg. Odds Sc Score
1 Marc Lyle $5,939 +11.9% 60.3% 240-158 -117 33.12
2 Brooke Bennett $4,371 +13.2% 57.1% 161-121 101 30.54
3 Dana Lane $2,796 +4.4% 49.9% 281-282 110 5.92
4 Matt Fargo $1,618 +5.2% 44.8% 138-170 135 3.17
5 Mike Williams $1,564 +3.8% 51.0% 184-177 107 5.11
6 Dave Price $1,553 +2.3% 52.9% 301-268 -107 1.67
7 Dustin Hawkins $1,442 +4.9% 53.5% 138-120 -104 3.25
8 Ricky Tran $1,435 +5.4% 62.0% 114-70 -140 5.04
9 Sean Higgs $1,313 +1.7% 52.1% 336-309 -105 0.99
10 Info Plays $1,211 +3.4% 52.5% 159-144 -103 1.83
11 Brody Vaughn $1,097 +2.6% 51.6% 195-183 -102 0.90
12 Totals Guru $906 +2.4% 53.7% 175-151 -111 0.76
13 Sal Michaels $342 +1.9% 51.4% 76-72 -101 0.36
14 Stephen Nover $334 +3.2% 55.3% 47-38 -118 0.23
15 Kevin Young $324 +0.7% 51.1% 202-193 -105 0.01
16 Doc's Sports $256 +1.8% 52.9% 65-58 -110 0.05
17 Brandon Lee $194 +2.5% 53.1% 34-30 -106 0.36
18 Marc Lawrence $159 +2.6% 54.0% 27-23 -112 0.14
19 Jim Feist $50 +0.1% 52.5% 146-132 -111 0.00
20 Hunter Price $17 +0.1% 53.5% 145-126 -116 0.02

MLB Hot Streaks

Betting on sports can be a tricky business, and handicappers often experience hot and cold streaks throughout the season. Sometimes it can pay to ride the hot hand, following an expert who is on a good run. Here are our hottest handicappers with Major League Baseball over the last seven, 30 and 60 days:

PAST 7 DAYS
Service Profit ROI Pct WL
Brooke Bennett $1,194 +87.0% 84.6% 11-2
ProSportsPicks $872 +38.6% 85.7% 12-2
Oliver Smith $831 +41.7% 63.2% 12-7
Marc Lyle $668 +13.9% 63.2% 24-14
Totals Guru $583 +37.7% 71.4% 10-4
Kevin Young $510 +26.7% 64.7% 11-6
Brody Vaughn $502 +23.3% 63.2% 12-7
Cole Faxon $466 +24.0% 52.6% 10-9
Chip Chirimbes $405 +17.6% 60.0% 12-8
Pure Lock $392 +52.9% 83.3% 5-1
PAST 30 DAYS
Service Units ROI Pct WL
Brooke Bennett $2,771 +48.4% 73.5% 36-13
Marc Lyle $2,362 +13.2% 62.0% 88-54
Totals Guru $1,540 +24.1% 65.5% 36-19
Stephen Nover $1,197 +36.9% 76.0% 19-6
Brody Vaughn $911 +12.0% 56.9% 37-28
Cole Faxon $685 +9.3% 50.7% 35-34
Oliver Smith $522 +6.9% 50.8% 34-33
Marc David $513 +7.2% 55.7% 34-27
William Burns $455 +10.1% 61.8% 21-13
Black Widow $417 +8.0% 56.1% 23-18
PAST 60 DAYS
Service Units ROI Pct WL
Marc Lyle $5,600 +15.2% 63.4% 182-105
Brooke Bennett $3,192 +26.1% 62.9% 66-39
Totals Guru $1,683 +12.5% 59.0% 69-48
ProSportsPicks $1,078 +8.1% 64.4% 56-31
Frank Sawyer $811 +19.1% 67.7% 21-10
Marc David $772 +5.6% 54.7% 64-53
Brandon Lee $597 +10.5% 57.5% 27-20
Brian Bitler $465 +4.9% 52.2% 47-43
Ricky Tran $460 +3.8% 61.0% 50-32
Calvin King $389 +3.4% 52.9% 54-48